If you haven't been paying attention, Aaron Donald's unretirement may not alter your expectations. But if you have been following this storyline, you know this is not a publicity stunt. Donald truly is in football shape and has been participating in drills like the seasoned veteran that he is.
Still, his surreal return has not quite sunk in. NFL insider Ian Rapoport asks the glaring question of whether Donald will have a limited role this season and for how long. That's fair. After all, Donald is returning from nearly three years of retirement. He's only just started practicing with his teammates.
But this is Aaron Donald, after all.
Ultimately, he will be a full-fledged starter. But a safe guess places Donald at around 500-700 snaps this season. His workload will gradually intensify as he acclimates to life in the NFL trenches. If you need a player to compare him to, the best example is nose tackle Poona Ford, who logged 508 snaps in 2025.
Rams' cat-and-mouse tactics only serve to confuse 49ers' Week 1 prep
While questioning what he has left in the tank is reasonable, it risks overlooking just how dominant Donald was throughout his 2014-2023 career. In short, a fraction of Donald is better than 100 percent of many starting defensive linemen. The thing is, more and more analysts believe Donald may be an early-season decoy.
Will he or won't he play in Week 1 is something everyone is asking. But the question only serves up more confusion for the San Francisco 49ers, who must prepare to face the Rams in Australia. Whether or not Donald plays will change how they get ready in a significant way.
If Donald sits, the 49ers must still contend with a fierce defensive front. Edge rushers Myles Garrett and Byron Young will be tough to fend off. But the Niners will feel somewhat confident that they can handle the workload.
Throwing Donald into the mix changes the matchups all along the line of scrimmage. Until proven otherwise, it's safe to assume that blocking schemes will double up on Garrett and/or Donald. That means other pass rushers, like Young or Kobie Turner, will need to overcome a single blocker.
Better still for the Horns, San Francisco will need to account for both scenarios. They can't be sure which version of LA's defense they will face.
Of course, fans want to know now whether Donald will suit up. But waiting a bit longer will only help the Rams' chances of winning an important game in Melbourne, and that is certainly worth waiting for.
As always, thanks for reading.
