You have to hand it to the Los Angeles Rams. They've certainly thought outside the box when it comes to forging new strategies to improve special teams. And some units have improved.
Other areas, however, have resisted those efforts. Coordinator Bubba Ventrone still needs to tidy up the kicking game.
After losing Blake Grupe to injury, the Rams didn't stop by adding Brandon McManus, their third kicker this season. They continued by re-signing Joshua Karty. Karty was released last season when his 'knuckle kickoff' attempts tarnished his field-goal accuracy.
His return was meant to optimize LA's defensive field position on kickoffs, with McManus used exclusively for field goals and extra points. Unfortunately, the results of Karty's kickoffs over three games are less than encouraging.
Rams' Joshua Karty trial no longer deserves the effort
The risk was worth taking. Deploying Karty exclusively for his touchback-inducing knuckleball, thus spotting opposing offenses at the 20-yard line, is certainly innovative thinking.
At this point, though, the team has enough evidence in the books to pull the plug on the experiment.
Half of Karty's kickoffs have produced a penalty or a kick into the end zone. Only two hit the landing zone and made it to the end zone, resulting in the ball being spotted at the 20-yard line. Six other kickoffs were returned. On average, opposing offenses have started at the 37.5-yard line.
That is not to say that Karty must go. He has followed orders to the letter. And with LA's bad luck this season, having a backup kicker on the roster or practice squad is very wise. But committing Karty to specialize in exploiting the new kickoff rules seems like a losing proposition.
McManus isn't going anywhere, either, for now. He has been perfect on five field-goal tries and 14 extra points. In 2025, Karty converted just 10 of 15 field goals and 23 of 26 extra points. Field-goal kickers can struggle at times. But just as quickly, they can reset and find their accuracy once more.
With work, Karty can reclaim his rookie proficiency.
Until then, it's time to resume the more conventional kickoff strategy. If the belief is that the team's coverage cannot stop the opponent's kickoff returns, then just kick it out of the end zone and prepare the defense to start from the 35-yard line.
As always, thanks for reading.
